The Problem with HOA Rules

Restricting dog heights through homeowner associations (HOAs) is a misguided approach that fails to consider the well-being of both dogs and their owners. While studies may suggest that larger guarding breed dogs are more suited for smaller spaces due to their quieter behaviour, these restrictions overlook the complex needs and individual differences of both dogs and their owners. This approach is flawed for several reasons:

Here are 7 Reasons dog height restrictions don’t work

One-Size-Fits-All Approach:

Imposing restrictions based solely on dog size disregards the fact that individual dogs have unique personalities, energy levels, and behavioural traits. Taking into account recent studies that show certain dogs are more prone to excessive barking and separation anxiety and they aren’t many large breed dogs in that category.  By treating all dogs of a certain size as if they share the same traits, HOAs overlook the diversity within breeds and individual variation.

Dog-Owner Compatibility:

Dog breeds are chosen by owners based on various factors, including the owner’s lifestyle, preferences, and needs. Restricting certain breeds based on size inhibits potential dog owners from finding a dog that suits their lifestyle and living situation. For instance, a responsible owner of a smaller breed may be fully equipped to handle separation anxiety and barking issues through proper training and care.

Limiting Housing Options:

HOAs that enforce strict height restrictions can limit housing options for residents, potentially driving away potential homeowners or renters who own dogs that exceed the prescribed height. This can have negative consequences on community diversity and discourage responsible dog ownership.

Discrimination Against Breeds:

Enforcing size-based restrictions can inadvertently discriminate against certain breeds or breed types, even if they are well-behaved and well-trained. This contributes to the perpetuation of breed stereotypes, ignoring the fact that behaviour is influenced by factors beyond just size.

Ignoring Training and Socialisation:

The behaviour of a dog is heavily influenced by proper training, socialisation, and the environment it is raised in. Focusing solely on size restrictions disregards the importance of these factors in shaping a dog’s behaviour.

Inequity in Enforcement:

Enforcing dog height restrictions can lead to inconsistencies in enforcement and disputes among residents. Differentiating between breeds based on height alone can be challenging, leading to potential conflicts between residents and the HOA.

Diminished Animal Welfare:

Restricting dogs to specific sizes without considering their needs can compromise their overall well-being. Dogs, regardless of size, require mental stimulation, exercise, and social interaction to lead healthy and happy lives.

Source: DogTown